← All episodes

EPISODE 45 / Mar 17, 2026

Stress with Jen Byrd-Craven

Jen Byrd-Craven·1h 33m·16 sections
LISTEN & EXPLOREOriginal episode ↗

Audio from the publisher. Timestamps reference the archived recording.

THE SHAPE OF THE CONVERSATION

Follow a thread through time.

Select a section to see what’s discussed, read the transcript, or listen from that moment. Topic tracks may overlap.

Loading the conversation timeline…

The conversation, in brief.

In this episode of the podcast, hosts Dave Pietraszewski and David Pinsof are joined by guest Jen Byrd-Craven to explore the endocrine system, stress, and evolutionary psychology. The speakers discuss the evolutionary history of human life history stages, energy allocation, and sex differences in stress responses. They examine how stress functions as a mechanism for mobilizing energy when demands exceed resources, and investigate the physiological impacts of co-rumination, childhood adversity, and unpredictability. Additionally, the conversation covers parental investment, testosterone shifts in fatherhood, and how media markets leverage evolutionarily recurrent stressors.

QUESTIONS TO KEEP IN MIND

  • How does the endocrine system help organisms prioritize energy allocation across different life history stages?
  • What differences exist between male and female stress responses emerging at puberty?
  • In what ways does childhood adversity and resource unpredictability calibrate the human stress response and metabolism?
  • How do vicarious stress and co-rumination contribute to social bonding and costly signaling?
  • Why might the human stress response err on the side of overproducing energy during novel situations?

Ideas to take with you.

  • Jen Byrd-Craven notes that childhood functions as a feeding adaptation that frees mothers from lactation. 8:51
  • Jen Byrd-Craven points out that females tend to show greater reactivity to subtle social rejection compared to males. 20:53
  • Jen Byrd-Craven explains that stress occurs when environmental demands exceed available resources, disrupting homeostasis. 27:05
  • Jen Byrd-Craven describes laboratory findings showing that a friend listening to another person's problem will also mount a physiological stress response. 32:52
  • Jen Byrd-Craven notes that the human body tends to overproduce energy when dealing with uncertainty and novelty for the first time. 43:55

Through the conversation.

16 sections
01
0:00 – 8:02

Introduction and the Endocrine System

Hosts Dave Pietraszewski and David Pinsof introduce guest Jen Byrd-Craven to discuss the endocrine system, stress, and evolutionary psychology. The speakers examine why humans possess an endocrine system alongside a brain, comparing computational and embodiment perspectives on motivation.

the endocrine system is a beautiful system to be able to tell us what organisms are prioritizing in the moment

“the endocrine system is a beautiful system to be able to tell us what organisms are prioritizing in the moment” 3:08
02
8:03 – 12:02

Childhood, Puberty, and Life History Evolution

The speakers discuss the evolutionary functions of childhood, puberty, and extended human life history stages. They explore how childhood serves as a feeding adaptation and a protected period for learning complex social environments, culminating in distinct human life history traits like menopause.

childhood essentially is a feeding adaptation, and to be able to free mother up from lactation

“childhood essentially is a feeding adaptation” 8:51

we have a new a number of unique life history factors. So, you know, I mentioned childhood and adolescence. We also have menopause.

“we have a new a number of unique life history factors” 11:41
03
12:02 – 19:00

Evolutionary Nniches, Energy Allocation, and Endocrine Mechanisms

Dave Pietraszewski, David Pinsof, and guest Jen Byrd-Craven discuss the evolutionary history of human social selection, extractive foraging niches, and how energy allocation across the lifespan is regulated by endocrine mechanisms.

endocrine mechanisms that uh uh that channel uh energy allocation in different directions

“endocrine mechanisms that uh uh that channel uh energy allocation in different” 15:33

universals in human development

“universals in human development” 18:16
04
19:00 – 24:02

Puberty, Stress Responses, and Sex Differences in Social Motivation

Jen Byrd-Craven, Dave Pietraszewski, and David Pinsof explore sex differences in stress responses emerging at puberty, noting that males tend to show stress responses to public achievement stressors while females are more reactive to subtle social rejection.

that difference doesn't show up until puberty

“that different doesn't show up until puberty” 19:41

Women are much more reactive to social rejection

“Women are much more reactive to social rejection” 20:53
05
24:02 – 32:14

Defining Stress and Dismantling Common Intuitions

Host Dave Pietraszewski and guest Jen Byrd-Craven discuss the adaptationist perspective on stress, noting discrepancies between self-reported stress and physiological measures. Byrd-Craven explains that stress is fundamentally about mobilizing energy when demands exceed resources, noting that even positive experiences like romantic love or anticipating holidays can elicit physiological stress responses.

when the demands exceed the resources, you're going to experience, you know, sort of a disruption in homeostasis

“when the demands exceed the resources, you're going to experience, you know, sort of a disruption in homeostasis” 27:05

the HBA axis is more recruited when that doesn't work.

“the HBA axis is more recruited when that doesn't work.” 27:45
06
32:14 – 36:05

Vicarious Stress Responses and Social Bonding

Jen Byrd-Craven describes her laboratory research on co-rumination among friends, explaining how listening to a friend's problems outside the dyad triggers a physiological stress response in the listener as well. The hosts and guest discuss how vicarious stress and emotional involvement help signal reliable coalition partnership and foster social bonding.

the friend whose problem it is not hers will also mount a stress response.

“the friend whose problem it is not hers will also mount a stress response.” 32:52

by showing that you're sort of, you know, you're engaged in this process, um, you're, you know, sort of um trying to unpack this with them

“by showing that you're sort of, you know, you're engaged in this process, um, you're, you know, sort of um trying to unpack this with them” 35:38
07
36:05 – 43:25

Stress Signaling and Developmental Inoculation

Dave Pietraszewski, David Pinsof, and guest Jen Byrd-Craven discuss how stress functions as a costly and honest signal of fitness interdependence and allyship. They also explore developmental aspects of stress, arguing that avoiding all stressors or bubble-wrapping children can stunt their ability to cope with normal challenges and lead to hyper-reactive stress response systems.

part of the stress response may be a kind of costly signaling of interdependence

“part of the stress response may be a kind of costly signaling of interdependence” 36:59

kids that don't have those experiences grow up to have overactive stress response systems

“kids that don't have those experiences grow up to um have overactive stress response systems” 41:50
08
43:26 – 48:06

Energy Calibration and Cognitive Mismatch in Stress

The hosts and Jen Byrd-Craven examine how the body learns to self-regulate and allocate the appropriate level of energy during recurring challenges, noting that cortisol helps restructure neural networks. They also discuss whether modern stress responses to purely cognitive challenges, such as a math test, represent an evolutionary mismatch where the body overshoots energy expenditure.

our body errs on the side of overproducing energy when dealing with uncertainty for the first time

“our body errs on the side of overproducing energy.” 43:55

cortisol is responsible for destabilization of neural networks, but also reconnection

“cortisol being responsible for destabilization of neural networks, um, but also reconnection” 45:00
09
48:06 – 56:12

Evolutionary Design and Misconceptions of Stress

Host Dave Pietraszewski and guest Jen Byrd-Craven discuss whether the human stress response is poorly designed, arguing instead that activating multiple systems in novel situations is a functional error-management strategy. They examine how modern social media and attention markets exploit these evolved mechanisms through sensationalized content and outrage.

Byrd-Craven notes that experiencing novelty triggers an all-systems-go response that is well designed for new contexts.

“when we experience novelty, then that's you know, sort of all systems go.” 53:02

Pietraszewski suggests that advertising and media capture attention by leveraging evolutionarily recurrent stressors.

“evolutionarily recurrent stressors are really, as you would expect, really good at capturing attention.” 54:15
10
56:12 – 1:00:06

How Stress and Energy Regulation Shape Attention

The hosts and guest explore how stress impacts cognitive processing and brain function rather than just physical responses. They discuss why attention and neural inhibition are metabolically expensive, requiring energy to prioritize relevant stimuli and suppress competing physiological demands like digestion.

Byrd-Craven explains that the stress response regulates arousal and attention to prioritize environmental stimuli.

“It regulates attention, right? Um it regulates arousal and attention towards, you know, one stimuli over another.” 56:55
11
1:00:06 – 1:04:51

Neural Networks, Energy Allocation, and Stress

Hosts Dave Pietraszewski and David Pinsof discuss with guest Jen Byrd-Craven how attention and mental effort are allocated during stressful situations. They explore the hypothesis that restructuring neural networks and encoding detailed information during critical events is energetically demanding, and touch upon how individuals recover after periods of high stress.

could it be that um the restructuring of our neural networks is energy intensive

“could it be that um the restructuring of our neural networks is energy intensive” 1:01:47

people come out of a super high stressful abusive relationship and they just like they have to unwind

“people come out of a super high stressful abusive relationship and they just like they have to unwind” 1:04:09
12
1:04:51 – 1:12:09

Childhood Adversity and Calibrated Stress Responses

Guest Jen Byrd-Craven and the hosts examine how childhood environments and social unpredictability calibrate human stress response systems and future orientation. They discuss how individuals from chaotic or high-adversity backgrounds adapt their vigilance and diurnal stress patterns to match their specific ecological contexts.

all adversity isn't the same

“all adversity isn't the same” 1:06:21

the tendency of the body to store energy in the form of fat for the future is or may be caused by an unpredictability in the available food sources

“the tendency of the body to store energy in the form of fat for the future is or may be caused by an” 1:11:11
13
1:12:09 – 1:14:50

Stress, Childhood Development, and Calibrating to Unpredictability

Host Dave Pietraszewski and guest Jen Byrd-Craven discuss the relationship between stress, future discounting, and metabolic calibration. They explore how early childhood environments and resource unpredictability shape developmental outcomes such as obesity and metabolism, noting that abstract social cues and stress can exert profound physiological effects on the developing body.

kids that are more impulsive, they're less able to wait for long-term rewards

“kids that are more impulsive, they're less able to wait for long-term rewards” 1:12:23

abstract cues can have a very concrete, even developmental or kind of calibrational effect on us

“very abstract cues can have a very concrete, even developmental or kind of calibrational effect on us” 1:14:15
14
1:14:50 – 1:24:10

Parenting Stress, Status Motivation, and Fatherhood

Guest Jen Byrd-Craven joins hosts Dave Pietraszewski and David Pinsof to discuss how parents navigate stress and risk-taking in children. The conversation shifts to ongoing research on human fatherhood, rough-and-tumble play, and hormonal shifts like testosterone decreases associated with parental investment and heightened empathy.

parents sometimes will, you know, make sure that their kids do that, you know, homework

“parents sometimes will, you know, make sure that their kids do that, you know, homework” 1:16:12

when you become a father, if you are investing, you experience a little decline in testosterone

“when you become a father, if you are investing, you experience a little decline in testosterone” 1:22:54
15
1:24:10 – 1:27:29

Parental Investment and Intergenerational Status Competition

Dave Pietraszewski, David Pinsof, and guest Jen Byrd-Craven discuss evolutionary perspectives on parental investment, arguing that parents invest in children's social status and competencies because offspring face an intergenerational arms race. They also touch upon political indoctrination, cultural transmission, and religious adherence among youth.

It's just as much of an arms race their generation as it was for yours.

“It's just as much of an arms race their generation as it was for yours.” 1:24:41

I think it does speak to this adaptive problem of ensuring that the kids don't grow up to shake up the political alliance structure.

“adaptive problem of ensuring that the kids don't grow up to, you know, uh shake up the the political alliance structure” 1:26:55
16
1:27:30 – 1:31:55

Episode Wrap-up and Musical Teasers

The hosts conclude the interview with Jen Byrd-Craven, transition into casual banter about podcast production, music composition, and playing the acoustic guitar, and joke about future incentives for Patreon supporters, including a custom song and an AI simulation of Charles Darwin.

Dave and David wrap up the interview and chat about show logistics, music creation, and upcoming listener incentives.

“Well, well, Jen, thank you so much for coming on. It was a pleasure.” 1:27:30